Appeal court finds no errors in earlier decision on Alberta's professional standards for engineers
EDMONTON (CP) — An Alberta court has dismissed an appeal application by a foreign-trained man who wanted to work in the province as an engineer.
Ladislav Mihaly, who was educated in the former Czechoslovakia, had been seeking to register with the Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of Alberta.
The association required Mihaly to write exams to confirm his credentials, but after failing tests he filed a complaint with the Alberta Human Rights Commission.
In 2014, a human rights tribunal ruled the tests were discriminatory and ordered the association to reconsider Mihaly's application and pay him $10,000 in damages.
Last January, an Alberta Court of Queen's Bench judge reversed the tribunal's decision, saying the ruling was based on errors and was unreasonable.
Mihaly filed an appeal, but the Alberta Court of Appeal dropped it in June when he failed to follow up.
In a ruling released Thursday, Justice Frans Slatter of the Appeal Court dismissed Mihaly's application made in December to restore his appeal.
"As far as the merits of the appeal, the appellant does not point to any patent error on the face of the decision under appeal," Slatter wrote.
"Even Canadian educational institutions must demonstrate the equivalency of their programs, and Canadians who receive foreign training must also demonstrate equivalency."
Mihaly could not be reached for comment.
Carol Moen, registrar of the engineers association, said the regulator considers the case to be closed.
"It reconfirms that APEGA's application process is fair, equitable, and transparent, and serves the public interest," she wrote in an email.
"Regardless of where applicants for licensure studied, the same rigorous standards apply. Lowering the standards used to examine if an individual has appropriate education and experience to be licensed would result in an unacceptable increased risk to Albertans."
Mihaly's case has been watched by other professional regulatory organizations across Canada.
In its 2014 ruling, the human rights tribunal said many immigrants from Eastern Europe, Africa and Asia experience disadvantage and discrimination in the workforce because of language, culture and racial prejudice.
It said imposing additional exams or requirements without flexible individual assessments restricts the ability of immigrants to work in their professions and could lead to immigrants taking lower-paying jobs in other fields.
